We Tasted Every Fall Drink on Our Menu So You Don't Have to Settle for Pumpkin Spice
Photo: || UggBoy♥UggGirl || PHOTO || WORLD || TRAVEL ||, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Every October, the same ritual plays out across America: somebody hands you a pumpkin spice latte, you drink it, and you spend the rest of the cup quietly asking yourself whether you actually like it or you just like September.
We got tired of the ambiguity. So last week, we pulled every fall drink on our board — plus a few experiments — set them up as a blind-ish tasting at the counter, and put them in front of five staff members and a suspiciously willing group of regulars. Here's how it went down, ranking by actual votes, with plenty of strong opinions attached.
The Contenders
Six cups, same espresso base across the milk drinks, all made to spec:
- Classic pumpkin spice latte (house pumpkin syrup, cinnamon, nutmeg)
- Maple cortado
- Cinnamon cardamom latte
- Brown butter toffee latte
- Straight double shot of our current single origin, nothing added
- A honey-cinnamon cappuccino
Tasters ranked their top three. Coffee was consumed. Friendships were briefly strained. Science was done, loosely.
The Results, With Feelings
1. Maple cortado — the upset winner. Look, we love a latte, but the cortado's 1:1 ratio of espresso to steamed milk is exactly what fall flavors need. The real maple syrup doesn't get lost under a wall of foam; it folds right into the shot. One taster wrote, verbatim, "tastes like the first cold morning." Five first-place votes. It wasn't close.
2. The straight double shot — yes, really. The plot twist of the tasting. Our current single origin is a washed Guatemala with notes of cocoa and dried cherry, and when tasters compared it side by side with the flavored drinks, the room had a small crisis. The flavored syrups, several people admitted, were masking a bean that tastes like fall all on its own. Which is kind of our whole point.
3. Cinnamon cardamom latte — the sleeper hit. Cardamom is doing all the heavy lifting here, and it plays beautifully with espresso's natural sweetness. If pumpkin spice is a costume, this is a well-tailored coat.
4. Brown butter toffee latte — dessert in a cup, and we mean that as half a compliment. Two second-place votes, but also one comment that just said "a lot." Fair.
5. Honey-cinnamon cappuccino — perfectly pleasant, criminally forgettable. It came in fourth in a five-horse race and nobody fought for it.
6. Pumpkin spice latte — last place. Before the PSL loyalists light their (scented) candles: it's not bad. It's fine! It's the seasonal equivalent of a movie you put on in the background. But when it went up against the maple cortado in a head-to-head sip, the consensus was instant and brutal: the pumpkin version tastes like a syrup with coffee in it, while the cortado tastes like coffee with a season in it.
The Case for Letting the Bean Do the Talking
Here's our actual position, stated with all the neutrality of people who run a coffee stand: pumpkin spice became the default not because it's the best fall flavor, but because it was the loudest. A big chain made it a phenomenon, and now it shows up every August like a relative who arrives early to Thanksgiving.
But autumn's flavor palette is bigger than one spice blend. Maple. Cardamom. Brown butter. Toasted nuts. Dark honey. And above all — the coffee itself, which at this time of year is often freshly harvested from the most recent picking season and tasting fantastic without any help.
Our suggestion for the season: order one drink you always get, and one thing off the beaten path. Get the PSL if it genuinely makes you happy — we'll never judge, Dorothy certainly won't — but make the second cup a maple cortado and see if your October changes.
If you take one thing from this taste test, let it be this: the season should be in your cup because of care, not because of a pump. Come by and we'll pour you both. You can nod your verdict. We've gotten very good at reading nods.